United Citizens for Livingston County (UCLC) Exhibits

UCLC 1 – Kevin Parzyck, Invenergy, material copy from presentation given at the Illinois Wind Working Group, Siting, Zoning and Taxing of Wind Farms in Illinois Conference 2012, New Technology Impact on Health & Safety Issues, February 8, 2012.

UCLC 2 – Copy of the Livingston County Illinois Zoning Regulations

UCLC 3 – Andre, et al. v Invenergy, LLC New York Supreme Court, Complaint No. 46912 filed on August 5, 2014

UCLC 4 – Slowinski v Invenergy, LLC, New York Supreme Court, Complaint No. 46066 filed on September 24, 2013

UCLC 7 – Williams v Invenergy, LLC, US District Court, District of Oregon, Case No. 3:13-cv-01391-PK, filed on August 9, 2013

UCLC 8 – dailyreporter.com Article, Noise Complaint Generates Wind Farm Fears (UPDATE) by Paul Snyder, April 2, 2010

UCLC 10 – Copy of an article titled; “Preliminary studies on the reaction of growing geese (anser anser f. domestica) to the proximity of wind turbines.”

UCLC 13 – Copy of the Livingston County Comprehensive Plan, Year 2020 Update.

UCLC 14 – Copy of the Official Filing Before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin – Docket No. 2535-CE-100 – Application of Highland Wind Farm, LLC etc. – Direct Testimony of Joanne J. Blank.

UCLC 15 – Copy of a list of; “United Citizens of Livingston County”, Updated November 19, 2014

UCLC 16 – References Can Wind Turbine Noise Harm Human Health?, Jerry L. Punch, PhD, Presentation

UCLC 17 – Jerry Punch, PhD, Power Point Presentation, Can Wind Turbine Noise Harm Human Health – FILE TOO LARGE TO UPLOAD

UCLC 20 – Copy of Alec Salt and Jeffery Lichtenhan’s document titled; “Perception – based protection from low-frequency sounds may not be enough”

UCLC 21 – Copy of Articles in Press, Hearing Research, Review Article titled; “Responses of the ear to low frequency sounds, infrasound and wind turbines”

UCLC 22 – Copy of a Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society with a title of; “Infrasound From Wind Turbine Could Affect Humans”

UCLC 26 – Copy of a document titled; “Systematic Review 2013:  Association Between Wind Turbines and Human Distress”

UCLC 28 – Before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin, Rehearing Testimony of Dr. John S. Lamancusa (St. Croix, WI)

UCLC 29 – Copy of Report Number 122412-1, Issued December 24, 2012 with a title of; “A cooperative Measurement Survey and Analysis of Low Frequency and Infrasound at the Shirley Wind Farm in Brown County, Wisconsin.

UCLC 34 – A Cooperative Measurement Survey and Analysis of Low Frequency and Infrasound by the Shirley Wind Farm in Brown County, Wisconsin prepared by Dr. Bruce Walker, George F. and David M. Hessler, Robert Rand and Paul Schomer (12/24/2012)

UCLC 40 Group 1 – Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (2014-2015 Edition) from the Appraisal Foundation

UCLC 40 Group 2

UCLC 40 Group 3

UCLC 42 – Department of Energy Website Page

UCLC 43 – Department of Energy Website Page

UCLC 44 – Case Studies Re: Increase/Decrease of Market Value of Property near Wind Turbines, Diminition/Change in Price, Prepared by Ben Lansink (Lansink Appraisals & Consulting) (02/2013)

UCLC 60 – Resume of Aaron Nathaniel Gruen

UCLC 61 – Comments, Findings and Conclusions about Report by David G. Loomis, PhD entitled Economic Impact of The Pleasant Ridge Wind Energy Project” by Gruen, Gruen & Associates

UCLC 62 – The Economic and Fiscal Benefits of the Shady Oaks Wind Farm.  Goldwind.

UCLC 63 – Testimony of Gruen (includes comparison of 2012 Shady Oaks to Pleasant Ridge proposal)

UCLC 70 – Appraisal Report, Property Value Impact & Zoning Compliance Evaluation re: Pleasant Ridge, prepared by McCann Appraisal & Consulting LLC (02/06/2015) Too Large to Upload

UCLC 71 – Property Value Impact & Zoning Compliance Evaluation re: Pleasant Ridge, prepared by McCann Appraisal & Consulting, LLC (02/10/2015)

UCLC 72 – Wind Farms, Residential Property Values, and Robber Rulers – by Albert Wilson, 2010

UCLC 73 – Professional Profile of Albert R. Wilson (as of 04/15/2009)

UCLC 74 Group 1 – Impact of Industrial Wind Turbines on Residential Property Assessment in Ontario (2012 Assessment Base Year Study), prepared by MPAC (Municipal Property Assessment Corporation)

UCLC 74 Group 2

UCLC 75 – Direct Testimonies of Joseph Yunk, Ann Wirtz & Others re: Highland Wind Farm Application before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (2012) (Photos, Inc.)

UCLC 79 – Property Value Guarantee Agreement (between property owners and Wind Energy Center within Livingston County)

UCLC 80 – Participation Consideration of the Pleasant Ridge Wind Farm (PRWF) by Nelson Zehr (Fairbury, IL)

UCLC 103 – Forrest Meeting Agenda

UCLC 104 – 24370 E. 500 North Road Aerial

UCLC 114 – EVA’s Decommissioning Estimate for Pleasant Ridge Wind Farm, prepared by Thomas A. Hewson

UCLC 115 – Resume of Thomas A. Hewson, Jr.

UCLC 122 – Aerial of 13113 N 2500 East Road

UCLC 126 – Computer printout from the IL EPA Fact Sheets re: Smith Douglass Site in South Streator, Illinois. (Ambrose)

UCLC 130 – Analysis of Predicted Noise Levels for the Pleasant Ridge Wind Energy Project prepared by Marcus Maier of SE Livingston County – PARTS ADMITTED

UCLC 131 – Letter from Stephen Ambrose (of S.E. Ambrose & Assoc.)(Acoustics, Environmental Sound & Industrial Noise) to Hartke (Hartke Eng’g) re:  His Review of Noise Level Compliance  Analysis Re: California Ridge Wind Energy Project – saying that the report was not credible. (12/04/2014) – NOT ADMITTED

UCLC 132 – From the Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society – Wind Turbine Noise article prepared by John P. Harrison – NOT ADMITTED

UCLC 133 – NY State Dept. of Environmental Conservation (Div. of Water) Letter to Stony Creek Energy LLC (Falls Church, Virginia) re:  Notice of Violation of the Stony Creek Wind Farm Substation Site.  It was discharging water and sediment to a small creek

UCLC 134 – Kaisner Aerial

UCLC 150 – IPCB Charter Hall Homeowners Association and Jeff Cohen vs. Overland Transportation and DP Cartage, Inc.

UCLC 151 – A Theory to Explain Some Physiological Effects of Infrasonic Emissions at Some Wind Farm Sites

UCLC 153 – IPCB Hoffman vs. City of Columbia

UCLC 154 – IPCB Noise Pollution Control Regulations

UCLC 156 – IPCB Part 900 General Provisions

UCLC 159 – Measurement Techniques

UCLC 160 – Assessor Data Sheet for 13665 E. 3000 N. Rd. Blackstone

UCLC 161 – MLS #06891540 Data Sheet 13665 E. 3000 N. Rd., Blackstone

UCLC 162 – Assessor Data Sheet for 9210 E 1700 N Rd., Graymont

UCLC 163 – MLS #07056825 Data Sheet 9210 E 1700 N Rd., Graymont

UCLC 164 – MLS #104055 Data Sheet 20558 E. 100 North Rd., Fairbury

UCLC 165 –  Assessor Data Sheet 20558 E. 100 North Rd., Fairbury

UCLC 166 –  Assessor Data Sheet 4667 E. 1600 N. Rd. Flanagan

UCLC 167 –  MLS #104101 Data Sheet 4667 E. 1600 N. Rd. Flanagan

UCLC 168 – Aerial Photo of Pin #13-26-400-014

UCLC 169 – Assessor Data Sheet for 12610 N. 1900 E. Rd., Fairbury

UCLC 170 – MLS #104457 Data Sheet 12610 N. 1900 E. Rd., Fairbury

UCLC 171 – Aerial Photo

UCLC 172 – Aerial Photo  Pin #28-05-200-021

UCLC 173 – Aerial Photo Pin #14-15-200-017

UCLC 174 – Assessor Data Sheet for 10322 N. 2315 E. Rd., Fairbury

UCLC 175 – MLS #103360 Data Sheet for 10322 N. 2315 E. Rd., Fairbury

UCLC 176 – Assessor Data Sheet for 17670 E. 3200 N. Rd., Blackstone

UCLC 177 – MLS #103892 Data Sheet for 17670 E. 3200 N. Rd., Blackstone

UCLC 178 – Photograph #1 – 17670 E. 3200 N. Rd., Blackstone

UCLC 179 – Photograph #2 – 17670 E. 3200 N. Rd., Blackstone

UCLC 180  Aerial Photograph Pin #’s 02-17-100-002, 02-17-100-019, and 02-17-100-012

UCLC 181 – Assessor Data Sheet for 24458 N. 2500 E. Rd., Odell

UCLC 182 – MLS #07992812 Data Sheet for 32900 N. 2000 East Rd., Dwight

UCLC 183 – Assessor Data Sheet for 21379 E. 3100 N. Rd., Dwight

UCLC 184 – Assessor Data Sheet for 29227 N. 2300 E. Rd., Odell

UCLC 185 – MLS #105553 Data Sheet for 29227 N. 2300 E. Rd., Odell

UCLC 186 – Assessor Data Sheet for 10725 E. 1700 N. Rd., Pontiac

UCLC 187 – Assessor Data Sheet for 14-14-477-001

UCLC 188 – County Information for 14-14-477-001

UCLC 189 – MLS #105706 Data Sheet for 10725 E. 1700 N. Rd., Pontiac

UCLC 190 – Assessor Data Sheet for 18375 E. 2500 N. Rd., Odell

UCLC 191 – MLS #08715711 Data Sheet for 18375 E. 2500 N. Rd., Odell

UCLC 192 – Google Earth Arial Photo

UCLC 195 Group 1

UCLC 195 Group 2

UCLC 195 Group 3

UCLC 195 Group 4